It Cosmetics CC Cream Illumination Foundation vs. Original (& CC Eye!)
09 • 03 • 2015
Recently It Cosmetics released two followup products to their best-selling Your Skin But Better CC Full Coverage Cream SPF 50 Foundation (whew- that’s a mouthful!) I have owned the original CC Cream for awhile, but recently I’ve been loving the new It Cosmetics CC Cream Illumination (a more shimmery version of the original), and also the CC Eye Full Coverage cream. I’ve been using these fantastic It Cosmetics very consistently lately, so I thought I would discuss the differences between these three products and give my recommendations. PS– as always I bought all three of these products with my own hard-earned money, so this post is in no way sponsored by It Cosmetics.
Although I still love my cheapo Garnier BB Cream (full post about that here), lately I’ve been reaching for my new It Cosmetics CC Cream Illumination instead. It has several benefits over the Garnier– there’s no drying alcohol in it (unfortunately when you first put on the Garnier, it smells overwhelmingly like alcohol), and sometimes I feel like the Garnier is a little dry for around my eyes. Also the It Cosmetics has a high concentration of physical sunscreen– Titanium Dioxide 9.0% + Zinc Oxide 6.3% to provide broad spectrum physical protection (read my post here to make sure you understand the important difference between physical and chemical sunscreens), so that is a bonus when you’re at the pool or in the mountains where higher altitude means the sun is stronger.
The It Cosmetics CC Cream is also more hydrating than other foundations or BB Creams I have tried. I really do think it has made a difference in the appearance of fine lines, especially toward the end of the day when I start to look dry around my eyes and those fine lines become more prominent. All the It Cosmetics CC Cream products contain Hyaluronic Acid, Peptides, Hydrolyzed Collagen and Silk, Grape Seed Oil to provide hydration benefits.
Interestingly, I wear the Fair (lightest) shade in the original CC cream, but the Light (second lightest) shade in the Illumination version. The original CC cream in the Light shade reads a little orange or dark on my skin, but the shimmer that is in the Illumination version somehow helps match it to my skin tone better.
Here is a swatch of It Cosmetics CC Cream Illumination (in Light) on the left, Original version (in Fair) on the right:
People do complain that the shade range is not wide enough (there are five shades in each formulation), but I think each shade in the Illumination line varies slightly from the corresponding shade in the original formulation, so you have a few more options to find your match.
I’ve decided I prefer the Illumination version of the CC Cream over the original (non-shimmery) version, but it might just be because the color matches my skin better. The Illumination version has a finish that is very similar to the Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer “Radiance.” When I use the Original CC Cream, I usually set it with Hourglass Ambient Light Powder in Ethereal Light to add a little bit of glow. But since the new CC Cream Illumination version is so shimmery by itself, I have been preferring to set it with matte It Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores Silk HD Anti-Aging Micro-Powder. Shimmer on shimmer can look fakey and exaggerate pore size.
Also I’ve noticed that some bloggers say that they can’t tell a difference between the finishes of the two versions, but I disagree. I think the Illumination version is much more obviously glowy, but when you set the Illumination with the Bye Bye Pores, or set the Original with glowy Hourglass Ambient Light Powder, the finish ends up about the same.
Want to see the beautiful coverage of CC Illumination? Here’s what my skin looks like without any foundation– my main struggles are dark under eye circles, melasma/sun damage on my cheekbones, and redness from veins around my nose. Oh, and I have a birthmark on the side of my face but it doesn’t really bother me:
Now here are several views of me wearing the It Cosmetics CC Cream Illumination, with a little bronzer (Too Faced Endless Summer 16-hour Bronzer) and set with It Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores Silk HD Anti-Aging Micro-Powder. The CC Cream Illumination does an amazing job covering up discoloration and redness, and together with the Bye Bye Pores powder, it looks like my skin has been airbrushed! The powder makes a big difference in pore size, and definitely improves the wear time of the foundation.
I tried to take the photo as close up as possible so you can see that it doesn’t look like heavy foundation once it settles into your skin:
See that airbrushed look and fantastic glow?? You really don’t need a luminizer or highlight on your cheekbones if you use the CC Illumination– that glowy look that highlights your bone structure is already taken care of in one step!
Here are two finished looks where I’m wearing the It Cosmetics CC Illumination– no Photoshop used, I promise!
My tips for using It Cosmetics CC Cream:
–You can use a foundation brush to apply, and some people think this method helps you use less product. But I prefer the look of it when I apply with my plain ol’ fingers.
–Some bloggers recommend that you wear the CC Cream over a primer, but I think it looks better without a primer. The CC Cream actually has its own primer already built in, plus Anti-Aging Hydrating Serum (including Snail Secretion Filtrate, which is exactly what you think it is). I’ve found that if I layer a primer underneath it, it tends to sit on top of the skin a little more, and look less natural.
–I recommend spraying your face with Urban Decay All Nighter Makeup Setting Spray to vastly extends the wear time of the It Cosmetics CC Cream. I used to use makeup setting spray only for special events, but when I realized what a difference it makes in keeping your makeup on, now I never leave home without a quick spritz. And if I get in the car and realize I forgot to spritz, I feel mildly panicky. It’s that effective.
CC+ Eye Color Correcting Full Coverage Cream:
Oh, and what about the new It Cosmetics CC Eye? It touts the same 7-in-1 skincare benefits and physical SPF 50, but formulated for your eye area. This does not have as much coverage for under eye circles as a true concealer like Bye Bye Under Eye or my current favorite Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer. I also did not notice a significant decrease in puffiness from the “Cold Spoon Technology” applicator. But I do like this product and use it regularly because it brightens and smooths and moisturizes.
I actually don’t use it in conjunction with the It Cosmetics CC Cream Foundation– that would be redundant. But I do apply it in my eye area before I use my Garnier BB Cream (All Day Shine Control version). I love the finish and coverage of that BB cream, but I did notice that it was a little drying around my delicate eye area. Once I started layering the It Cosmetics CC Eye underneath, I had no problems and my eye area stayed moist and not crepey or fine-lines. So to me, if you have combo skin where you need to control oil on your t-zone, but you are dry around your eyes, the CC Eye is a game-changer.
Hope that helps clear up the difference between these three amazing It Cosmetics CC products!
I was so amazed with your skin after you used the Illumination CC cream that I sprang for it. Wish me luck. It’s hard buying makeup on line, you never know quite what you’re going to get. Thanks!
Thanks so much, Pam!
Thanks for this. I found CC to be orange so never did try the illumination version!
Is your skintone pink? I am neutral so things always look pink or yellow on me :(
I’d say my skin tone is neutral toward yellow. I found the regular CC in shade Light to be orange on me, but the Illumination version is not. I wear the “Fair” shade in the original CC. Hope that helps!
First of all, I have to give you mad props (Or or whatever the current version of that term equates to) for paying for your product and telling us that you do. When bloggers and reviewers state that they were given the product or paid to do the review, it loses all credibility, and I move right along to the next one.
Your review of the IT Cosmetics and the comparisons with other familiar brands was great. I was fearful of getting the orange tone, because I’m definitely neutral. Your explanation of regular CC and CC Illumination swayed me to settle on Medium and to go ahead and try it. I was stuck on picking a color!
This is the best review I’ve read in a long time. Everything from adding primer to brush/ fingers. Comparing brands to similar products.
I hope this works out. I’m a night owl and I’ve almost pulled the trigger several times on Bye Bye Cosmetics. I hope the Medium works. It’s odd some ppl say it doesn’t work for them. And that it ages them 15 years. That’s one I read. Do you think they’re putting too much on?
They just had double bonus size shimmer CC at TSC and I just bought the light. Fingers crossed we are the same shade!
OK I’ve been looking for something like this a long time,i don’t wear a lot of make up because I’ve always been fortunate to not having any skin issues,however I’m older now and have always wanted that dewy glow I see on a lot of you better informed women.i was contemplating a product well known brand,forgot but called Glow BB cream.Now after reading your great review,think I’ll buy this one.My question is can I wear it alone.Just never was one use a lot of products as far as foundation,powder.BTW,you look beautiful,obviously you know what you’re doing.Certainly would not use around my eye wrinkles.Great review and thank you!!
Thanks for validating my thoughts on this one! It’s a lovely product (the best BB/CC type base I’ve found in the American market) but it looks pretty terrible over primer! I have a few high-end primers (Benefit, Estee Lauder, etc.) that work with most my other foundations, but specifically not with IT Cosmetics. I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who had the same results!
I finally tried it and I love it. I’m a die hard charlotte tilbury magic foundation user, but I just received my CC Illumination in shade medium and obsessed!!! I can’t believe it took me this long to finally try it.